Hold Me Closer, Necromancer Review
October 9th, 2010 | Published in review, writing
Hold Me Closer, Necromancer is a Young Adult novel by Lish McBride (who appears to have a temporary site up at lishmcbride.com). At first it seems like it might fall too well into the oversaturated subgenre of teen-paranormal-romance, but fortunately she takes it in a different direction (much like the fun Dust of 100 Dogs).
The story follows Sam, a college dropout who begins the book working in fast food, and appropriately snarky about it. Then he learns that there is something special about him, something special that draws the attention of a very scary man (as you might guess from the title, the book has a strong supernatural element to it). Action, drama, comedy, and romance all ensue.
The short version is that this is an extremely entertaining book. It was well written, and would appeal to anyone with a sense of humor. It is clearly intended as the first book in a series, and I look forward to the next one. The very short version is this: go read it.
All of that being said, there are a couple of rough edges that I want to point out. I am doing this primarily for my own benefit (as a writer it is important to be able to critique), but I thought that the wider world might benefit from this too. If the author happens to read this post, I don’t mean to be overly harsh, and I would hope that she in no way took this as a sign that she shouldn’t go on producing awesome fiction (and heck if she’s just totally pissed off at what I say, she (or anyone else (yes, I know I’m nesting parentheses, sue me)) can drop me a line and tell me so (if it makes them feel better)).
Here There Be Spoilers
My first issue with the book was the inclusion of Douglas Montgomery’s backstory early on. Basically, chapter three was a flashback to his childhood. The chapter was well written, but it really didn’t serve much purpose. Douglas’s actions throughout the book did a great job of showing what an asshole he was. The only real bit of information that we gained was that he was able to suck the power out of other necromancers, and that is what he was planning on doing to Sam, which could have been worked in just about anywhere else. And normally this sort of thing wouldn’t have been such a big deal, but the story basically stopped moving forward for a chapter, squandering momentum (sure, it showed him planning on killing Brooke, but the reader would have figured it out by the end of the next chapter anyway, at the latest). Since this is a novel, it does have to have a minimum length, so the argument could be made that this chapter couldn’t be cut. The flashback could be moved to a more appropriate spot or more time could have been spent developing Brid’s character, which brings me to my second point.
Brid first shows up in chapter five, which takes the reader away from Sam’s story again, but it wouldn’t have been so bad if chapter three hadn’t been spent with Douglas (after chapter five, the reader has spent about 40% of the book so far with characters who are not the primary viewpoint character). My issue with Brid, though, is her lack of development. She is shown only in the context of her relationship to the pack, she has no life outside of it, there is no tension between the two worlds in which she lives. I would much preferred to learn more about her than Douglas. Second, her character felt a bit like fanservice, which isn’t the worst thing in the world, but bothered me nonetheless. Were-hound or no, I just don’t buy her being ok with being naked, especially while being held prisoner in a cage.
Finally, the sex. It was tastefully done, which is more than many books can say, but I felt that it wasn’t used to its fullest effect. I understand the whole “it’s the end of the world, let’s get it on” thing, but again, it felt a bit like fanservice. I would have been much happier if the author had played it for more tension at the end, when Sam was in the hospital. If he had done more second guessing their relationship, when he didn’t hear from her immediately, it would have totally been worth it, but to me there was no tension in it, no worry that she had only jumped his bones out of desperation or that her father was going to tear his throat out.
All in all, the main issues wasn’t that anything was wrong, but rather that there were missed opportunities, all of which amounted to little more than annoyances for me. The author didn’t seem hesitant or timid, and I especially appreciated that she was willing to kill off likeable characters (Brooke’s death was a surprise, and used to great effect). The characterizations, description, dialogue, were all great, and the storytelling never felt heavy handed. I’m looking forward to him dealing with his uncle, the pack, Ramon, his half-siblings, the big-ass raven, and the fact that he might have a darkness at the very core of his being.
All in all, a great read.








